The BSA A7 & A10 Forum
24.05. 2012 05:02 *
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
News: Best Picture poll still open for votes
 
   Home   Help Search Login Register  
Pages: [1] 2   Go Down
  Print  
Author Topic: Problems with Petsealed tanks and modern fuels - a warning  (Read 2161 times)
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
alanaitch
Active
*

Karma: 1
Posts: 7



« on: 21.10. 2010 18:24 »

A couple of weeks ago, after two years work and a lot of cash spent, I finally finished building my beautiful BSA Rocket Gold Star replica (see pic).

She started first time, and sounded great.

Given that I hadn’t yet got her registered, all I could do was ride her up and down my (private) road to get the bugs ironed out.  So each day for the following week, you’d find me, chuffed to bits, riding to and fro, until one morning she wouldn’t start and was spitting back through the carb.  I also noticed that the compression was nowhere near what it was when I first started the engine.

I went through all the normal checks – fuel, spark, plugs etc and everything was OK, but when I came to check the compression, there wasn’t any on the left-hand pot.

So, off with the rocker covers to make sure the valve clearances hadn’t closed, only to find that as I turned the engine over on the kick start, only the exhaust rockers moved!  The inlet rockers just stayed where they were!

At this point I decided to take the bike back to the guy who built most of the engine for me for him to diagnose the problem.

After taking the rocker box and head off, he found that both inlet valves were stuck fast in the guides, and that there was a hard, sticky residue on the top of the guides (see pic).

On top of that, both inlet pushrods were badly bent (see pic).

After some cogitating, he realised that the Petseal sealant that had been used when the petrol tank had been restored was being dissolved by the petrol – now known as the ethanol problem.  So the fluid reaching the carbs was a very sticky solution of petrol and Petseal, which had built up on the valve stems and set hard.  Finally, enough had been deposited to cause the valves to stick, with one partly open, bending both pushrods.

In addition, the back of the inlet valve heads and the inlet ports were coated with the stuff and the carburettor completely gunged up.

After an awful lot of work including using strong solvents to remove the deposits from the valves and ports, reaming the guides to get rid of the stuff from there, stripping and cleaning the carb, fuel lines and filters, removing the rest of the Petseal from the tank, fitting 4 new pushrods, reassembling the head and putting everything back together again, the bike is now back to first class running order.

So my advice to anyone with a bike that has a tank that has previously been sealed with Petseal is DON’T START THE ENGINE until you’ve removed all of the Petseal from the tank.  Chris Williams at Autocycle Engineering can provide a solvent to remove it.  If you still need to seal the tank, Tank Care Products (http://www.tankcareproducts.co.uk) claim to have an ethanol resistant sealant, although I cannot verify that – you’ll have to make your own mind up.

I hope that my experience will save many of you similar or even worse problems.

Alan



* RGS.jpg (99.89 KB, 640x426 - viewed 75 times.)

* Head.JPG (308.48 KB, 1600x1200 - viewed 112 times.)

* Pushrods.JPG (155.11 KB, 640x480 - viewed 57 times.)
Logged
alanp
Plymouth, Devon
A-Clairvoyant
****

Karma: 6
Posts: 403



« Reply #1 on: 21.10. 2010 18:37 »

That's interesting for me since I bent a push rod and also had that junk on the back of the inlet valves - and my tank hasn't got any extra lining!!!
I'm going to check out my petrol pipes to see if its coming from a reaction to them. A friend with a 60's Honda kept having sticky throttle slides with gummy stuff building up on them. He currently is running with a fuel line filter to see if it collects anything.
Alan
Logged

Member of the 'Last of the Summer Wine Club - Jennycliff'.
trickytree
A's best friend
***

Karma: 1
Posts: 148


Lincolnshire, England


« Reply #2 on: 21.10. 2010 19:54 »

Im in the proccess of replacing the treated tank on my bobber with a untreated one. My tank wasnt done with petseal but the stuff imported by Wassell, so I doubt that it is a quality product.

Although the bike has been running great and I have done about 1500 miles on it I have had to strip the carbs due to sticking slides. I also noticed alot of build up on the inlet valve the other day (I could see it through the spark plug hole). I put it down to the bike burning oil as there was a bit of play in the valve guides when I reassembled the motor, but there simply wasnt enough cash in the pot to do owt about it at the time. Now you have got me thinking that perhaps it could well be a sealant problem as well??

I have heard that POR15 is also ethanol resistant also.

Logged

1965 A65 Bobber
A10 Bitza project
muskrat
Forum Oracle
*****

Karma: 25
Posts: 1879


Lake Conjola NSW Oz


« Reply #3 on: 21.10. 2010 21:19 »

A good warning to all Alan. A shame you found out the hard way.
 I used it to seal a oil tank. I didn't think of the blow by and fuel (methanol) mixing with the oil. Lucky I had a oil pressure guage fitted. Started up with 50lb but after 1 lap had nil. Start up again after a few minutes and 50lb again. One more lap, nil. A flap of the sealant was covering the oil feed line, but once the motor was stopped the flap would float back up. eek
Cheers
Logged

Only young once, immature forever. Now how can I make this go faster. '51 A7 plunger, '57 A7SS now A10, '71 A65 Lightning (gone to god) '76 XT500, '83 CB1100F, next project a '64 A65.
chaz
Very active
**

Karma: 2
Posts: 61


WWW
« Reply #4 on: 21.10. 2010 21:30 »

interesting story. wonder if its a recent batch process problem?
Ive used petseal for years in A65's, A7,T100,  just about to use it in another A7, and also customers Yamaha TDR250, Kawasaki Zephyr amongst others and never had a problem , may pay to ask if they have changed the make up of it.
Logged

allways willing to learn
alanaitch
Active
*

Karma: 1
Posts: 7



« Reply #5 on: 21.10. 2010 22:07 »

Chaz,
It's not a problem with a specific batch of Petseal, It's due to the fact that the petrol companies are now adding ethanol to their fuel...and the ethanol dissolves the Petseal.  You can speak to Chris Williams at Autocycle Engineering or John Phelan at Sheffield British Motorcycles and they'll both tell you not to use it.  Shame I didn't speak to them earlier!!
Regds
Alan
Logged
nagrod
Active
*

Karma: 0
Posts: 28


1960 BSA Super Rocket


« Reply #6 on: 21.10. 2010 22:35 »

I have heard similar comments about Kreem, which is upsetting since I finally broke down Kreem coated the tank on my '60 A10 early this summer. Of course I didn't hear any bad press about it until after I coated it. Timing is everything! I haven't run the bike enough to have seen an engine problem (It's still a work in progress). Has anyone heard more about Kreem products and problems? And does any one know how it's removed if it needs to be?

Rick
Logged

'Never again. But that's what I said the last time.'
BSA_54A10
Forum Oracle
*****

Karma: 11
Posts: 727


WWW
« Reply #7 on: 21.10. 2010 23:09 »

Kreem is a different product and has a slightly different affect.
It will also dissolve in the muck we are sold as "petrol"
There are a lot more solvents in "fuel" other than ethanol.
A lot of petro chemical solvents have been banned from common use.
However they are still made as they are a by product of petrol refining .
The solution is to add them back into the "petrol" that we use.

Kreem when exposed to whatever brew we get in NSW Australia dissolves rapidly.
When enough has dissolved it turns what is in the tank into a non volatile liquid.
I had a bloke tearing his hair out with a bike that would not run, got got into the workshop for a thorough going over.
It would then start and run fine as it was being fed with fuel from a different tank on an overhead stand ( I use the same set up).
When reassembled with it's own tank and brand new fuel it would run fine, the client would take the bike home, big smile on his face.
Next week it would not run quite as well and a week latter it would not even start.
Back to the shop it went.
The mechanic finally tried a little test, he poured the fuel out of the dead bike into his own bike and that would not start either.
New fuel in the tank and all was well so the tank sat in his shop and he tried it every couple of days and sure as !!!! is brown within 4 to 8 weeks the fuel had go off to an extent that the bike would not start.
Cleaned the old fuel out of every thing and the cycle was repeated, worked fine for a couple of weeks then slowly went totally off.

So he sent the tank out for a strip and recoat with POR 15 and it is smiles all round, but this process hast taken the better part of 2 years to nail down and sent more than one bloke bald.

So yes tank sealants are now prime suspects for every problem that gets presented to me.
I am not trying to start a tank sealant panic but if you have sealant in your tank and are experiencing some unusual problems , have a good look at the fuel. Sorry to hear of your problems Alan but as you can see you are not alone and the fuel companies are to blame.
I wonder if any one has come to physical grief or even died when his fuel would no longer burn in his bike.

Logged

Bike Beesa
Trevor
brackenfel
A-Clairvoyant
****

Karma: 2
Posts: 272

Adrian - Bristol UK


« Reply #8 on: 22.10. 2010 19:57 »

I'd heard about this at the local AJS & Matchless OC... None of my bikes have been sealed as far as I  can tell.

A quick search on Google and the first two links are :-

http://www.jawaczownersclub.co.uk/technical_advice13.htm

http://driversalliance.org.uk/press/view/348


Doesn't look too good.. I've always used "Super" unleaded in the Velo which happens to have a Mk1 Concentric fitted.. I think I'll go back to the standard "Premium" rubbish as it may just contain a bit less ethanol....

Cheers,
Adrian
Logged

1961 A10 650 Golden Flash - Blue
1954 BSA B33
Velocette Viper
Laverda 750 SF1
Kawasaki W650
Buell XB9S
Ariel 350NH & Matchless G3LS in bits...
Desburnett
A's best friend
***

Karma: 0
Posts: 114

BSA A7 SS, Fazer 1000, Norton Commando 850


« Reply #9 on: 22.10. 2010 23:56 »

Had virtually the same problem last week, see my earlier post "Stuck Valve" Originally thought I had over revved and caused valve spring bounce but after stripping down had exactly the same symptoms.
I believe the valve guides were originally cast iron which to a degree are self lubricating with free graphite. Not too keen on the phosphor bronze versions. One point I would check is the lack of a chamfer in the bore of the guide in the stem end. The guides that I was supplied with lacked any chamfer which prevents any oil build up in this area again reducing lube to the valve stem.

Des
Logged
alanp
Plymouth, Devon
A-Clairvoyant
****

Karma: 6
Posts: 403



« Reply #10 on: 23.10. 2010 14:23 »

Des, are you talking about a chamfer at the top of the guide (rocker box end) or bottom?
Alan
Logged

Member of the 'Last of the Summer Wine Club - Jennycliff'.
dpaddock
NC, USA
A-Clairvoyant
****

Karma: 5
Posts: 430



« Reply #11 on: 23.10. 2010 23:29 »

I "Kreem"-ed my Goldie tank (steel) in 2000 and the coating is still firm and sound.  I know of one other tank that was Kreem-ed; it's a fiberglass tank and the coating has gone soft and pulled away.

I coated my steel Spitfire tank earlier this year with the Caswell product, and it's fine so far.

One thing for sure: prepare the surface exactly per the manufacturer's instructions and proportion and mix the ingredients precisely.

David
Logged

David
'57 Spitfire

Desburnett
A's best friend
***

Karma: 0
Posts: 114

BSA A7 SS, Fazer 1000, Norton Commando 850


« Reply #12 on: 24.10. 2010 00:02 »

Alanp. Chamfer was missing in top of guide rockerbox end.
Des
Logged
gold33
Very active
**

Karma: 0
Posts: 95



« Reply #13 on: 25.10. 2010 02:00 »

On the fuel front,
Had a chat to a disgruntled workshop Manager on Saturday, he filled a just finished bike with 98oct fuel from a local Mobil station, tuned the bike and felt pretty good about himself, the next day the bike took quite an effort to start, the day after it wouldn't start at all...
After a couple of weeks of playing on and off he discovered a sticky residue in the carby (tank not lined), long story short the fuel was dissolving the fuel lines! It also dissolved the plastic cover off his feeler gauges after he soaked them in the fuel to clean them up.
Logged

Darren
'52 Plunger
taroha10
Active
*

Karma: 0
Posts: 41

1961 super rocket. 1950 m20.


« Reply #14 on: 25.10. 2010 22:22 »

Evening all,Thanyou Alanaitch for your warning .
Now i'm in a quandary.I did the tank of my M20 with Petseal a few years back.I have not had any problems so far but obviously am concerned.I am usually a bit wary of those sort of products but it has been excellent and cured the leak I had.It seems that the modern fuel is causing problems to many who have used these products.I know no-one can tell me exactly what to do but has anyone found they are not having problems.Also has anyone flushed the tank with solvent and been fairly sure the sealent has all come out?Other than that it is maybe unweld the tank and shotblast it off.The good thing is that the bike is laid up needing a fork overhaul and I do have a very rusty but spare tank.And the super Rocket dosn't seem to have any coating in it's tank.Cheers to you all.Mark.
Logged
chaz
Very active
**

Karma: 2
Posts: 61


WWW
« Reply #15 on: 02.12. 2010 19:14 »

the guy next door to me races and runs Frazer Nash cars from the thirties, his classic car magazine also reports that the additives introduced to fuel is having adverse affects on brass and copper fittings as well.

he has given me a tin (empty) of Northern Fuel Tank Liner from America, its what they use, would one of our American members like to check if this product is any better and if anyone knows of an importer to the UK?

their web site has documents but Im not sure if its any good. their web site
  http://www.northernfactory.com/storefrontB2CWEB/browse.do?action=refresh_browse&ctg_id=193918

as an aside to this subject Ive a customers Kawasaki W650 mdern day twin in for MOT and check over as running a bit lumpy, hasnt done many miles this year and looking in the tank noticed its going rusty, for a 1999 bike looks like we may have a problem,,,....
Logged

allways willing to learn
chaterlea25
Forum Oracle
*****

Karma: 14
Posts: 818


« Reply #16 on: 02.12. 2010 21:10 »

HI All,
A further issue has raised its ugly mug on a Velo I did some work on recently  sad2
The fuel has reacted with the "rubber" seals in the new petrol taps I fitted, they expanded and blocked the flow???
The taps were supposed to be suitable for "ethanol blend" huh2?
I have also had the issues with the dissolving petrol pipe, Again supposed to be and marked as suitable huh2

There is a solvent available to dissolve and remove petseal, no need to cut open the tank smile
I have several bikes with petsealed tanks,I'm not looking forward to having to re do them All sad2

Regards
John O R
Logged

1961 Super Rocket
1963 RGS (ongoing)
flashblack
West Devon, England
A's best friend
***

Karma: 1
Posts: 212


1959 golden flash


« Reply #17 on: 02.12. 2010 21:13 »

Draganfly are now selling a tank sealer they claim to be petrol/ethanol proof. Maybe someone on here knows something about it? Maybe worth further investigation.
regards Richard.
Logged

build it, ride it, live it!
chaz
Very active
**

Karma: 2
Posts: 61


WWW
« Reply #18 on: 02.12. 2010 21:21 »

Ive got to ring them for square 4 parts so will ask tomorrow and post reply
Logged

allways willing to learn
chaz
Very active
**

Karma: 2
Posts: 61


WWW
« Reply #19 on: 02.12. 2010 23:04 »

just got a reply from Northern ...
I am going to make the assumption that you mean ethyl alcohol. Tank liner will work with ethyl alcohol fuel mixtures, but it best with steel tanks. Tanks made of fiberglass would not work as the liner will not adhere to it.

anyone any experience?
Ive also got a royal enfield continental gt in with a split fibreglass tank and cant find anyone to repair, was hoping topetseal the inside to seal the fibreglass but now thats a problem
Logged

allways willing to learn
Pages: [1] 2   Go Up
  Print  
 
Jump to:  

Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1.16 | SMF © 2011, Simple Machines Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!